Member-only story

Lenin's Jewish Question: Abigail Rutherford's Investigation into Historical Antisemitism and State Suppression

Lord Byron

·4.2k Followers· Follow

Published in Lenin S Jewish Question Abigail Rutherford

5 min read

610 View Claps

36 Respond

Save

Listen

Lenin's Jewish Question: Abigail Rutherford's Investigation Into Historical Antisemitism And State Suppression Lenin S Jewish Question Abigail Rutherford

The Jewish Question has been a contentious issue throughout history, with varying degrees of antisemitism and persecution. In the early 20th century, Russian revolutionary leader Vladimir Lenin penned a controversial pamphlet titled "The Jewish Question" (1913),offering his perspective on the subject. However, this pamphlet remained largely unknown until recently, when it was discovered and translated into English by Abigail Rutherford.

Lenin's Jewish Question

by Abigail Rutherford

4 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	2002 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Print length	:	228 pages

Rutherford's work has sparked renewed interest in Lenin's views on Judaism and has raised questions about the role of antisemitism in the Soviet Union. This article will delve into the contents of "The Jewish Question," examining Lenin's arguments, their historical context, and the implications for understanding the nature of antisemitism and state suppression.

Lenin's Arguments in "The Jewish Question"

In "The Jewish Question," Lenin argued that antisemitism was a product of capitalism and class struggle. He viewed Jews as an oppressed minority exploited by the bourgeoisie and used as scapegoats to deflect class tensions. Lenin believed that the only way to eradicate antisemitism was to overthrow capitalism and establish a socialist society.

Lenin also distinguished between two types of antisemitism: "reactionary antisemitism," which he condemned as irrational and backward, and "progressive antisemitism," which he saw as a legitimate criticism of the bourgeoisie's use of Jews to oppress the working class. This distinction, however, has been criticized for being overly simplistic and potentially justifying antisemitic rhetoric.

Historical Context and Antisemitism in the Russian Empire

To understand Lenin's views on Judaism, it is essential to consider the historical context of the Russian Empire. Antisemitism was widespread in Russia, with Jews facing legal and social discrimination, pogroms, and other forms of persecution. The Russian Orthodox Church played a significant role in fostering anti-Jewish sentiment, portraying Jews as Christ-killers and outsiders.

Lenin's critique of antisemitism was influenced by his socialist ideology and his opposition to the Tsarist regime. However, some scholars argue that his analysis was incomplete, as he did not fully address the deep-rooted religious and ethnic prejudices that fueled antisemitism in Russian society.

The Suppression of "The Jewish Question" and Soviet Antisemitism

"The Jewish Question" was initially published in a limited edition in 1913 and largely forgotten until it was rediscovered and translated into English by Abigail Rutherford in 2016. This suppression suggests that the Soviet regime sought to distance itself from Lenin's views on antisemitism, which could have undermined their official policy of internationalism and equality.

Despite the suppression of "The Jewish Question," antisemitism persisted in the Soviet Union. Soviet policies, such as the establishment of Jewish autonomous regions and the promotion of Yiddish culture, aimed to address Jewish concerns but did not eliminate the underlying anti-Jewish attitudes within the population.

Abigail Rutherford's Contribution and Implications

Abigail Rutherford's translation and analysis of "The Jewish Question" has shed new light on Lenin's views on antisemitism and the complexities of Soviet history. Her work has prompted scholars to re-examine the nature of antisemitism and the role of the state in suppressing uncomfortable narratives.

Furthermore, Rutherford's research highlights the importance of confronting historical antisemitism and its lingering effects. By bringing Lenin's pamphlet to a wider audience, she has contributed to a broader understanding of the challenges and complexities of combating hatred and discrimination.

Lenin's "The Jewish Question," rediscovered and translated by Abigail Rutherford, offers valuable insights into the historical antisemitism in the Russian Empire and the complexities of Soviet policy. While Lenin's analysis may be flawed in some respects, it nevertheless sheds light on the deep-rooted prejudices that continue to plague societies today.

Abigail Rutherford's work serves as a reminder of the importance of confronting uncomfortable historical narratives and the ongoing struggle against antisemitism and other forms of discrimination. Through her meticulous research and translation, she has contributed to a deeper understanding of one of history's most enduring and pernicious problems.

Lenin's Jewish Question

by Abigail Rutherford

4 out of 5